Back to Insights listing

Professional liability, Insolvency, Trusts, probate and estates: contentiousTuesday 5 November 2024

Blower v GH Canfields – claimant fails to establish case on negligence or causation

On 4 November 2024, the High Court dismissed the claim made in Blower v GH Canfields LLP [2024] EWHC 2763 (Ch), a professional negligence claim also involving trusts and insolvency issues.

Jonathan Seitler KC and Lemuel Lucan-Wilson (instructed by Womble Bond Dickinson) acted for the successful defendant, which was alleged to have been negligent in their conduct of a mediation of claims brought by a trustee in bankruptcy against family members of the bankrupt. The defendant had acted for the family members, and was said to have “over-settled” the claims on the basis that those claims would have been unsuccessful and/or the claimant could have set-off against them.

His Honour Judge Paul Matthews KC found that the defendant firm had at all times provided the correct advice regarding the strength of the claims which the claimant had been facing, noting that the set-off now claimed could not have operated on the facts in any event, nor could the trust interests have operated as the claimant submitted at trial. The Court also found that the claimant had failed to set-off her case on causation in the pleadings – simply stating what she would not have done, but then not setting out what she would have done or what would have happened (the claimant expressly rejecting the application of the loss of a chance doctrine).

Read the full judgment

People to view:

Share by: Email

Related Insights View all thought leadership

  1. Placeholder

    External Conferences

    IPA 2024 Roadshow Series

    Tuesday 12th November 2024
    Marsh, 1 Tower Place, London, EC3R 5BU

    Speakers:
    Lexa Hilliard KC | Marcia Shekerdemian KC

    View more
  2. Placeholder

    Events / Webinars

    Wilberforce Trusts Litigation Day 2025

    Monday 20th January 2025 | 9am - 6pm, followed by drinks and dinner
    InterContinental Park Lane, London

    £299 - £360 + VAT | 5.5 CPD CPD

    View more
  3. Placeholder

    Articles

    Testamentary capacity: warning signs and professional best practice

    Article by Simon Atkinson, 30th September 2024 To read or download this article as a PDF, please click here. The recent decision of Joanna Smith J in Leonard v Leonard [2024] EWHC 321 (Ch) is instructive for private client practitioners, non-contentious and... Read more

    By Simon Atkinson
    Monday 30 September 2024

    View more
  4. Placeholder

    Articles

    Guidance on representatives appointed under CPR 19.12: Answers… and more questions

    Article by Benedict Evans, 29th August 2024 To read or download this article as a PDF, please click here. 1. The role of a representative appointed to represent an estate for the purpose of litigation only was first created by section... Read more

    Tuesday 3 September 2024

    View more

View all thought leadership